CJ Carr takes a leap and Big 12 quarterbacks join the race: Week 10 Heisman Trophy Rankings

After an impressive performance against Miami, Notre Dame’s CJ Carr vaulted up our Heisman power rankings.


The CJ Carr-led Fighting Irish beat Miami last Saturday. Photo courtesy of Icon Sportswire via Getty Images.

The CJ Carr-led Fighting Irish beat Miami last Saturday. Photo courtesy of Icon Sportswire via Getty Images.


Week 10 featured the most intriguing Heisman showdown of the season to date. Miami and Darian Mensah travelled to South Bend to take on Notre Dame and CJ Carr. The result of that game painted a clear picture of the current Heisman picture. Carr took a huge step forward during that matchup that game, throwing for 319 yards and three touchdowns. Mensah threw for 269 yards and three touchdowns, along with one interception.  

A few Big 12 quarterbacks have also surged into the picture as the season reaches its downturn. With that being said, let’s get into the post-Week 10 Heisman rankings.

In terms of this year’s Heisman race, Notre Dame-Miami has been the most impactful duel of the season. Carr came into this game third in Heisman odds and had a huge opportunity to take a leap. He ended up playing at an elite level against the Hurricanes and looked far better than his opponent, Mensah/ Whenever Notre Dame needed a big play, Carr made it. 

Carr also showed off his elite skill of not getting sacked. He’s only been sacked twice this entire season and while this may be in part due to a good offensive line, he excels at avoiding negative plays. Carr solidified his place in the lead of this race after this performance and has himself in a good position moving forward to walk away with some end-of-season hardware. 

Mensah, like Jeremiah Smith’s Heisman season, will fall under the “what if” category. What if Malachi Toney didn’t get hurt?. Mensah and Toney looked like they would comfortably be the top two for the award, and this one injury may have taken it all away. 

Mensah showed some leaks in the ceiling against Notre Dame’s elite defense, which is truly the first elite defense he and the Hurricanes have faced all season. He settled down later in the game, but threw a back-breaking interception late in the third quarter. Mensah still has a chance at capturing this award, but after this loss and the loss of Toney, his path is far more challenging. 

Dampier has the potential to sneak his way into this Heisman race on one simple factor: his team’s success. Heisman voters love putting the best player on the best team into the race, regardless of how good that player has been. Don’t be mistaken, Dampier would deserve this nomination, but being on an undefeated Power 4 conference champion would do wonders for his case. 

Dampier is not an elite passer, but he is an elite play-extender and scrambler. He’s also managing to win his team games. Those factors are a combination for a potential Heisman-winning season. 

Mestemaker’s case for the college football keepsake is the opposite of Dampier’s. He’s got the stats that point to him being arguably the best quarterback in college football, which could hand him this award. 

Mestemaker leads Power Four quarterbacks in passing yards and touchdowns. While his team isn’t playing at the same level as the Utes, the Cowboys are still in the backend of the College Football Playoffs, along with the Big 12 title game race. Recent quarterbacks, like LSU’s Jayden Daniels, won the award purely based on his statistical output and not his team’s success. It’s not likely this ends up happening for Mestemaker, but it’s not impossible, either.

Follow @hudland42 on Twitter/X for more CFB content.

Team Rankings

1.Georgia9.42 BS
2.Notre Dame8.58 BS
3.Utah8.39 BS
4.UCLA8.24 BS
5.Wake Forest8.15 BS

View full list

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *